Carney Curve

Boston College course evaluations · every published number, ranked class by class

Positions account for how many records stand behind each number, so one perfect review does not outrank a semester of them. Every score shown is the real average — only the ordering is adjusted.

Class record · ENGL · MCAS

ENGL 1010

First Year Writing Seminar · 136 instructors on record · 442 sections

What the course score is made of
80BC evaluations442 records · weight ×1.0 · Fall 2021 – Spring 2026
Student reviewsno reviews — does not contribute
RateMyProfessorsno ratings — does not contribute

That is the class itself, averaged across everyone who taught it. Who taught it, and how each of them scored, is the board below — that is what a student picking a section is actually choosing between.

What the challenge rank is made of
12thMore challenging than 12% of BC classesranked against every one we hold
82BC — “Intellectually Challenging”442 records · raw score out of 100

Boston College's own “intellectually challenging” question for this class only — students answer it positively about courses that stretched them, so it measures intellectual challenge and NOT grading, workload or quality. Almost every BC class scores high on it, which is why it is shown as a rank rather than a score.

What the workload rank is made of
33rdMore work than 33% of BC classesranked against every one we hold
49BC — “Workload”442 records · raw score out of 100

Boston College reports workload for this class only as one of five bands, not as a number of hours, and it does not publish what the bands mean — so this site will not translate it into hours. Higher means more work, which is not the same as worse.

Limited to 15 students. Designed as a workshop in which each student develops a portfolio of personal and academic writing, the seminar follows a semester-long process. Students write and rewrite essays continuously, discuss their works-in-progress in class, and receive feedback during individual and small group conferences with the instructor. Students read a wide range of texts, including various forms of non-fiction prose. In addition to regular conferences, the class meets two hours per week to discuss the writing process, the relationship between reading and writing, conventional and innovative ways of doing research, and evolving drafts of class members.

The board

136 instructors · ranked on this class onlyCompare the top 3
Filters the rows below. Positions are always against the whole class, so a rank does not change when the list is narrowed.

Scores are real averages. The order also accounts for how many records back each one — the count is under every score — so one perfect review does not outrank a semester of them. 35 of the 136 rows carry a mark saying so.

RankInstructorOverallWorkloadChallengeRMP overall
1Amanda LabriolaEnglish999 records39th29th1009 ratings · all classes
2Sarah EhrichEnglish9513 records39th24thno page
3Alexander Saint-WidowEnglish fewer records995 records25th20thno page
4Chelsey GrassoEnglish976 records33rd19th1003 ratings · all classes
5Vincent PortilloAssistant Professor of the Practice · English9412 records39th11th965 ratings · all classes
6Angela MuirEnglish fewer records984 records30th15th1004 ratings · all classes
7Bonnie RudnerAssociate Professor of the Practice · English956 records29th27th8613 ratings · all classes
8Gregory PetershackEnglish939 records26th9th1002 ratings · all classes
9Rebecca RadilloEnglish9114 records43rd32nd867 ratings · all classes
10Shelley LinsoEnglish fewer records936 records43rd19thno page
11Charles RedmondEnglish fewer records945 records33rd16th1003 ratings · all classes
12Joanna RovinEnglish9210 records29th34th929 ratings · all classes
13Jessica OylerEnglish fewer records954 records39th26thno page
14Katherine ReardonEnglish943 records25th4thno page
15Kathleen SteeleEnglish909 records28th6th702 ratings · all classes
16Grace ArenasEnglish fewer records915 records40th12th902 ratings · all classes
17Jessica PauszekAssistant Professor; Director, First-Year Writing Seminar · English fewer records924 records29th17th1006 ratings · all classes
18Lorenzo PuenteEnglish Provisional fewer records952 records78th11th9817 ratings · all classes
19Dacia GentilellaUniversity and Capstone906 records28th14th829 ratings · all classes
20Simon ShankoEnglish fewer records923 records25th22ndno page
21Christopher BoucherProfessor of the Practice · English Provisional fewer records942 records25th29th9411 ratings · all classes
22Shilpi SunejaEnglish923 records25th5thno page
23Isabel LaneEnglish Provisional fewer records942 records25th5th1003 ratings · all classes
24Aeron HuntAssociate Professor · English Provisional fewer records1001 record21st867 ratings · all classes
25Megumi DemondEnglish Provisional1001 record9thno page
26Justin Brown-RamseyEnglish Provisional991 record25th25thno page
27Joshua NguyenEnglish888 records26th17thno page
28Chandler ShawEnglish fewer records904 records25th3rdno page
29Julia AdamoEnglish Provisional fewer records981 record25th11thno page
30Julia WoodwardEnglish Provisional981 record25th53rd1001 rating · all classes
31Veronica HouseEnglish Provisional981 record25th36thno page
32Elizabeth DellEnglish Provisional981 record25th40thno page
33Carlo RotellaProfessor · English Provisional971 record78th57th1006 ratings · all classes
34Kelly GrayEnglish Provisional961 record78th23rdno page
35Mara KnoeckleinEnglish Provisional912 records39th24thno page
36Collin PrattEnglish Provisional fewer records951 record78th33rdno page
37Jocelyn RiceUndergrad Management Honors/Ethics Provisional951 recordno page
38Troy WoolseyEnglish Provisional951 recordno page
39Juliana LundeEnglish Provisional912 records25th2ndno page
40Olivia KerstenEnglish Provisional fewer records951 record25th4thno page
41Yuchen XiongEnglish Provisional951 record25th2ndno page
42Lauren WilwerdingAssistant Professor of the Practice · English877 records47th21st863 ratings · all classes
43Avery TomasoEnglish Provisional fewer records941 record25th14thno page
44Garrett PattisonEnglish Provisional941 record78th39th1003 ratings · all classes
45Katherine GwydirEnglish Provisional941 record25th9thno page
46Laura SterrettEnglish Provisional941 record25th36thno page
47Patrick SanticEnglish Provisional941 record25th5thno page
48Susan RobertsAssociate Professor of the Practice · English877 records46th11th9015 ratings · all classes
49Tess KoettingEnglish8711 records43rd17th807 ratings · all classes
50Cassidy AllenEnglish Provisional fewer records931 record25th11thno page
51Daniel DoughertyEnglish Provisional931 record78th29thno page
52Fari CannonEnglish Provisional931 record25th21st1001 rating · all classes
53Jacob WirshbaEnglish Provisional931 record25th15thno page
54Grace ThayerEnglish Provisional921 record78th1stno page
55Katie PelkeyEnglish Provisional921 record25th11thno page
56Jared HackworthEnglish Provisional921 record25th1001 rating · all classes
57Gina CaseEnglish Provisional911 record25th5thno page
58Noora AlsabahEnglish Provisional911 record25th9thno page
59Amulya Ravitej BachalaEnglish Provisional882 records39th29thno page
60Alexander ZhuEnglish Provisional fewer records901 record25th1stno page
61Davis RogersEnglish Provisional901 record78th48thno page
62Grace GerrishEnglish Provisional901 record78th15thno page
63Remson DejosephEnglish Provisional901 record25th2ndno page
64Sabina SullivanEnglish874 records25th1stno page
65Jean FranzinoAssistant Professor of the Practice · English866 records39th22nd803 ratings · all classes
66Emma HammackEnglish Provisional fewer records872 records39th9thno page
67Heather BrennanEnglish Provisional fewer records891 record25th5thno page
68Grace DanciuEnglish Provisional881 record25th1stno page
69Lila AlonsoEnglish Provisional881 record25th4thno page
70Summer CardarelliEnglish Provisional881 record25th13thno page
71Mali BarkerEnglish Provisional871 record78th9thno page
72Julie DaiEnglish Provisional861 record25th26thno page
73Jenna MirchinEnglish Provisional861 record25th17thno page
74Christopher SchafaleEnglish Provisional861 record25th25thno page
75Deanna DanforthEnglish Provisional861 record78th25thno page
76Victoria OlivieroEnglish Provisional861 record25th3rdno page
77Paul LewisProfessor Emeritus · English Provisional852 records39th9th862 ratings · all classes
78Ellie LangeEnglish Provisional851 record25th9thno page
79Morrgan RosenbergEnglish Provisional851 record78th23rd1001 rating · all classes
80Rebekah MitseinAssociate Professor; Assistant Chair · English Provisional852 records39th25th964 ratings · all classes
81Megan LeaseEnglish Provisional851 record78th9thno page
82Kenneth HaleyEnglish Provisional851 record25th19thno page
83Piper LoehrkeEnglish Provisional851 record78th5thno page
84Margaret SummerfieldEnglish855 records25th2ndno page
85Catherine FisherEnglish Provisional841 record25th9thno page
86Matthew MerskyEnglish844 records25th29th388 ratings · all classes
87Eleanor ForestellEnglish Provisional841 record25th0thno page
88Abigail HarrisEnglish Provisional831 record78th15th1001 rating · all classes
89Sara LatiniEnglish Provisional821 record25th9thno page
90Megan CrottyEnglish Provisional fewer records821 record78th2nd628 ratings · all classes
91Hannah ClayEnglish846 records27th4th602 ratings · all classes
92Thomas Kaplan-MaxfieldAssociate Professor of the Practice · English846 records45th25thno page
93Michael LyonsEnglish Provisional832 records78th26th702 ratings · all classes
94Alianna GuerraEnglish Provisional801 record78th9thno page
95Christy PottroffAssistant Professor · English Provisional801 record78th41stno page
96Roxana Alvarez SanguinetiEnglish Provisional801 record25th12thno page
97Ryan FayEnglish Provisional801 record25th1stno page
98Shelby JonesEnglish Provisional fewer records801 record25th5thno page
99Noel IngramEnglish835 records33rd3rd801 rating · all classes
100Rose O'connorEnglish Provisional781 recordno page
101Quinn FisherEnglish Provisional fewer records781 record16thno page
102Matthew GannonEnglish Provisional812 records78th19th466 ratings · all classes
103James MasanekEnglish Provisional fewer records781 record25th29thno page
104Maren SchifferEnglish838 records43rd12th864 ratings · all classes
105Brendan MccourtEnglish Provisional771 record78th11thno page
106Liam SchmidtEnglish Provisional771 record25th1stno page
107Suzanne MatsonProfessor · English Provisional771 record25th15th564 ratings · all classes
108Emily BecklerEnglish Provisional761 record25th2ndno page
109Nicholas StinehourEnglish Provisional fewer records761 record25th0th602 ratings · all classes
110Martha HincksEnglish8314 records46th25th4811 ratings · all classes
111Tailor DolginEnglish Provisional751 record25th1stno page
112George O'harEnglish Provisional741 recordno page
113Grace WoodEnglish Provisional731 record78th19thno page
114Min SongProfessor; Department Chair · English Provisional fewer records731 record25th29th7014 ratings · all classes
115Krithika VachaliAssistant Professor of the Practice · English793 records43rd5th702 ratings · all classes
116Fiona SteacyEnglish773 records25th4thno page
117Julia DavidsonEnglish Provisional fewer records752 records39th1stno page
118Margaret FergusonEnglish8117 records33rd5th546 ratings · all classes
119Elizabeth KernsEnglish Provisional fewer records671 record25th9thno page
120Nell WasserstromEnglish Provisional742 records78th36th807 ratings · all classes
121John BlegenEnglish Provisional631 record25th0thno page
122Kat MatsonEnglish Provisional fewer records631 record25th4thno page
123Mallory HillaryEnglish776 records39th3rd743 ratings · all classes
124Kristin ImreEnglish Provisional601 record1stno page
125Paul SherbanEnglish Provisional fewer records601 record0thno page
126Lydia BuchananEnglish7814 records39th4th646 ratings · all classes
127Rachel LewisEnglish755 records25th3rdno page
128Kevin ReynoldsEnglish Provisional fewer records541 record25th0thno page
129Jordan ReanierEnglish745 records33rd9thno page
130Allison AdairProfessor of the Practice · English705 records45th51st805 ratings · all classes
131Sean MitseinEnglish Provisional fewer records592 records93rd33rd404 ratings · all classes
132Nicole FrisbeyEnglish fewer records685 records43rd1stno page
133Brian ZimmermanEnglish7422 records46th34th7214 ratings · all classes
134Beth BennettEnglish675 records78th3rdno page
135Melissa O'learyEnglish fewer records555 recordsno page
136Sebastian IvyEnglish5713 records79th16th3613 ratings · all classes

All 136 instructors listed.

How this board is orderedPositions account for how many records stand behind each number, so one perfect review does not outrank a semester of them. Every score shown is the real average — only the ordering is adjusted. The comparison here is the class itself: a thin record is read against how this class was rated overall, not against the university.

Every instructor with an evaluation record for this class is on this board — it is not a top ten, and nothing is hidden behind a “show more”. Overall is the instructor's blended score for THIS class only, and its one contributing source is Boston College's evaluations for the sections in the row's record count — nothing on this board is an average across the other things they teach. Workload and Challenge are RANKS against every class we hold, not scores: BC's questions all sit near the top of the 1-5 scale, so a raw number would put almost every row in the high eighties and tell you nothing. Challenge is BC's “intellectually challenging” item, which students answer positively about courses that stretched them — it is not a measure of difficulty or grading. Neither column is ever marked better or worse. 89 of 136 rows are marked provisional: fewer than 3 records stand behind the number. That is thin evidence, not a bad instructor — the record count is in every row. The RateMyProfessors column is an instructor's overall figure across everything they teach; that site has no course dimension, so it is shown for information and kept out of the ranking.

The line

All 13 items · means across 442 records
The Professor4 items
Clearly Explains MaterialThe instructor was effective at creating an understanding of difficult subject matter.
9030th pctl
Available Outside of ClassThe instructor was available for help outside of class.
9242nd pctl
Brings Out Your Best WorkThe instructor motivated me to do my best work.
9028th pctl
Sparked My InterestThe course stimulated my interest in the subject matter.
9025th pctl
The Course3 items
Well-Organized CourseThe course was well organized.
8938th pctl
Clear Learning GoalsThe learning objectives for the course were clear.
9037th pctl
Useful Beyond the CourseWhat I learned is applicable beyond this course.
8929th pctl
Assignments & Feedback3 items
Assignments Help You LearnAssignments and exams contributed to my learning.
8622nd pctl
Gives Feedback PromptlyI received feedback on my work in a timely manner.
8421st pctl
Meaningful FeedbackThe feedback I received on my work was meaningful.
8938th pctl
Workload, difficulty & attendanceNot ratings
WorkloadHow much work the course took outside class, on Boston College's five-band scale — the band boundaries are not published, so this is not a number of hours.
4933rd pctl
Intellectually ChallengingThe course was intellectually challenging.
8212th pctl
Attendance MattersAttending class was necessary to do well in this course.
8521st pctl

Bar length is the rank against every comparable record we hold, not the raw score: BC's questions all have a median around 4.5, so a raw-scale bar would be nearly full on every row and would tell you nothing. Every bar is one ink colour — nothing here is graded green or red. The hatched bars are not ratings at all: a higher number on either describes a different course, not a better one.

Game log

442 sections · newest first
InstructorTermSecInstrCourseWork
Rebecca RadilloSpring 202601888240
Joshua NguyenSpring 202603898840
Liam SchmidtSpring 202604776740
Alianna GuerraSpring 202605807660
Collin PrattSpring 202606959060
Avery TomasoSpring 202607948940
Tailor DolginSpring 202608756940
Jean FranzinoSpring 202609898560
Amulya Ravitej BachalaSpring 202610877140
Morrgan RosenbergSpring 202611857560
Elizabeth DellSpring 202612989140
Ellie LangeSpring 202613857540
Sara LatiniSpring 202614827640
Grace ThayerSpring 202615928260
Noora AlsabahSpring 202616918740
Brian ZimmermanSpring 202617606740
Yuchen XiongSpring 202618958240
Shelley LinsoSpring 202620929260
Quinn FisherSpring 2026217878
Joanna RovinSpring 202622878740
Gina CaseSpring 202623918240
Grace WoodSpring 202624737860
Rebecca RadilloSpring 2026259680
Susan RobertsSpring 2026269895
Dacia GentilellaSpring 202627838340

Showing the first 25.

How to read this boardInstructors are ranked on their record in this class only, never on their average across everything they teach. Scores are out of 100 — Boston College's 1–5 agreement scale, ×20, the way these numbers were printed for years. Workload is BC's own five-band figure, not a number of hours, and is shown as a rank. A dash means the question was not reported, and is never a zero.